Rapala World Record 468x60
Share :
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Question? surface iron reel
#1
Guys i am looking to buy a surface iron reel to pair up with surface irons, 40lb mono and my 9ft jig stick. I was thinking about the penn squall 30n and the daiwa segate 40h whuch ine would be better and why? Also for any suggestions i would like to stay under $180
thanks and tight lines Big Grin
Reply
#2
I use my daiwa saltist 30 and love it, but that will run you over $180. I dont know much about those 2 reels but I would say go look at both, hold them and see how they feel in your hands. Go with the one that feels best. Its mostly about personal preference in my opinion
The way to a fishermans heart is through his fly
Reply
#3
I got my Daiwa Grand Wave 30 on my Calstar 100J 10" jig stick. Work pretty nice, but soon I'm replacing it with a Penn Squall 15. Love the cast control, I'm getting old and the bird nest come visit me often.....haha
Eat what you kill !
Reply
#4
My first question is what is your budget?
Let God lead the way!
Give a man a fish he eats for one day, teach him to fish he eats forever!
Reply
#5
i want to stay within $180 bucks
What about the okuma cortez 12cs? about the smae price how does that compare?
Reply
#6
Penn squall is lever drag, I have had a fisherman tell me that they didnt like the lever drag for jigging. That okuma looks pretty awesome all around, the only thing the daiwa has on it is a higher gear ratio. Between those 3 I would probably go with the okuma
The way to a fishermans heart is through his fly
Reply
#7
the squall actually has some new star drag reels and that is the one i would be looking to get.
Reply
#8
(04-25-2013, 08:26 PM)redrock55 Wrote: Penn squall is lever drag, I have had a fisherman tell me that they didnt like the lever drag for jigging. That okuma looks pretty awesome all around, the only thing the daiwa has on it is a higher gear ratio. Between those 3 I would probably go with the okuma

Penn makes Squall both in lever drag and in the star drag. The star drag family is SQL 12,15,25n, 30,40. The lever Family is SQL30,40,50,60LD
(04-25-2013, 09:21 PM)KalicoKiller5 Wrote: the squall actually has some new star drag reels and that is the one i would be looking to get.

As for your request in pairing up with a 9ft jig stick. Your best bet is gonna be to get to a tackle shop and sit the reel on it first. A 9fter base maybe a little to wide for the smaller class Penn Reels (Cant speak for other manufactures reels but I'd check them out too first). The 30 and 40 size no problem. The 25n may fit depending on the jig stick your using.

Your ideal surface iron reel would be the Squall 25n or even the Fathom 25n. Now with putting 40lb on it will you be using braid backing? If not, you'll want to move to the 30 size reel for line cap.


(04-25-2013, 06:33 PM)Oatums Wrote: I got my Daiwa Grand Wave 30 on my Calstar 100J 10" jig stick. Work pretty nice, but soon I'm replacing it with a Penn Squall 15. Love the cast control, I'm getting old and the bird nest come visit me often.....haha

Oat check the width of the reel sit and the reel it's self. Make sure it's gonna for that beast rod.
(04-25-2013, 04:40 PM)KalicoKiller5 Wrote: Guys i am looking to buy a surface iron reel to pair up with surface irons, 40lb mono and my 9ft jig stick. I was thinking about the penn squall 30n and the daiwa segate 40h whuch ine would be better and why? Also for any suggestions i would like to stay under $180
thanks and tight lines Big Grin

The 30 would be a great fit for it, but would you consider paying a few bucks more and get the Fathom 30? Great reel and its the low end reel of the big brother Torque series.
Now when talking about gear ratio keep in mind that if the ratios are near each other the line
recovery plays a roll as well

Cortez 12 6:2:1 w/38" 18.4oz
Penn Squall 30 6:0:1 w/40" 18.5oz
Penn fathom 30 6:0:1 w/40" 18.4 oz
Daiwa seagate 40 6:4:1 w/48" 21.30 oz

Looking at this spec above Daiwa wins the battle when comparing ratio and line recover but it's heavy and when adding 40 lb on a 9 foot rod. It's gonna hurt if the bite goes WFO. I'd say the winner out of the 4 above if you were to consider the Fathom, would be the Penn Fathom 30. Weighs less ratio and line recovery good but the mechanic of its surpasses the Okuma and Daiwa.

Reply
#9
Hey SB I was thinking the same thing, but if it don't fit I have other rod to put it on. I have a Calstar 90J and 800m also. Thanks for looking out tho......
Eat what you kill !
Reply
#10
wow thats alot of info SB, all very good points, the older Newells had wide bases that was an issue for the smaller reels, but yes lots have went with seat design for rods size pair up. good to check that first.
Let God lead the way!
Give a man a fish he eats for one day, teach him to fish he eats forever!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
advt

hotboat.com